Does anyone else have mixed feelings about the whole "princess thing" going on? You see them everywhere. Part of me likes it. As a "grown-up," I confess there is still a part of me that loves the princess marrying her Prince Charming and going to live in the castle happily ever after. Maybe that's why I like books like
The Goose Girl by Shannon Hale, or other "princess" stories.
However, I have some issues with the princess thing, most especially, the Disney Princess thing. I have seen most of the Disney animated movies (many several times), and still enjoy some of them.

Cinderella was my favorite as a child--she served her cruel (and ugly) stepsisters and stepmother but still found time to care for others. She deserved a happy ending. But have any of you read
Cinder Edna by Ellen Jackson? Now, that's my kind of role model. If you haven't read it, check it out from your library. Cinder Edna is Cinder Ella's practical, ingenious neighbor who doesn't wait for a fairy godmother but learns all sorts of wonderful skills and ends up falling in love with the stuffy prince's younger brother and lives a life much happier and more fulfilled than Cinderella's.

Anyway, getting back to ripping the princesses.
Sleeping Beauty was an idiot because she touched the dumb spindle (and Maleficent was too scary for me--she even says the "h" word in the movie, which I found horrific as a child). Aurora seemed way too spacey for me.
And don't get me started on Ariel--while she had a lovely voice, she was irresponsible and inconsiderate. She defied her father (who, I admit, was overbearing) and nearly ended up killing all of the mermaids because of her selfish wish to be human with Eric. Thank goodness her dad and Eric bailed her out. And I find her attire too revealing.
Belle was pretty awesome and showed true heroism by giving her life to replace her father's. She cared for the Beast and grew to love him despite her fear. She also showed great courage in the face of adversity and stuck to her guns when the social pressure mounted for her to marry Gaston.
Mulan? Pocahontas? They were courageous. That's cool.
Jasmine? Don't get me wrong--if I were the sultan's daughter, I wouldn't have wanted to marry some pompous prince just because of a law. But her wardrobe? Gee, what a great message for young girls. The dress-up clothes they have for the "princesses" are almost as immodest.
Snow White was very sweet to the animals and the dwarfs. But how could she have fallen for the old "poison apple" routine? She was a bit too naive and dainty for me.
So what's the ideal princess for a cynical mom (tongue in cheek) like me?
When I was younger, my dad and I would read stories together. One of my favorites is Frances Hodgson Burnett's
A Little Princess. I hope you've read it (and the movie is fabulous, too).

In it, Sara Crewe is sent to a boarding school while her father goes away to war (World War I). She is wealthy, but she still is kind to the other girls, most especially those who are not befriended by the others. She shares her wealth with Becky, the black servant girl. When her father is killed (which really does happen in the book--the movie has a different ending), she loses her wealth and is forced to become a servant herself. Miss Minchin, the headmistress, is very unkind to Sara (no doubt she had a poor childhood herself, though) and in the movie tells Sara, "You'll do well to remember, Sara Crewe, that you are not a princess any longer" when she sends her up to her small, drafty attic bedroom.
Still, even as a servant, Sara shares a bun with an even poorer little girl than herself. She saves food for the little mouse who lives in the attic with her. She is still kind to the other girls. While at first disenchanted with her new reality, she revives her imagination and remembers her father's words, "I believe that you are, and always will be, my little princess." In the movie, Sara stares down Miss Minchin, telling her, "All girls are princesses. Even ones who live in tiny old attics."
And as her wise Maya told her at the beginning of the movie,
"All women are princesses. It is our right."True indeed. We are daughters of a King, our Heavenly Father. If I can help Clara understand that she is truly a princess because she is a spirit daughter of God, then I will feel that the whole "princess" thing is not for naught. However, I would rather have her look to Sara Crewe or Queen Esther than to Snow White for what it really means to be a princess.
So I say, bring on the tiaras and jewels and fancy dress-up clothes, but hopefully as a tool to teach the importance of acting like a princess, of acting like a daughter of God, on the inside. I love the magic of make-believe and think it is an important part of childhood (or adulthood, for that matter), but fairy tales come true only in so far as we choose to act like the princess we verily are in real life.

I'll get off my soap box now.